The BioPhorum "MES of the Future" manifesto progress report just dropped, and I have to say — it's incredibly validating to see where the industry has landed three years after that initial call to action.
As someone who's spent the last decade obsessing over what makes MES truly transformative (and frankly, what makes most legacy systems fall short), I am ecstatic this publication affirms: we've largely solved the technical challenges of next-gen MES. Now our biggest hurdle is adoption.
But here's what's fascinating: we've reached an inflection point that I don't think the industry fully recognizes yet.
Looking back at the evolution of MES technology and the Apprentice journey, we can trace a clear progression:
For years, pharmaceutical manufacturers were ahead of the technology curve. Teams knew what they needed but couldn't find MES vendors who could deliver it. Technology was the bottleneck.
That dynamic has completely flipped.
We're now in the age of Agentic MES capabilities — AI agents that autonomously execute complex manufacturing activities. Meanwhile, many organizations are still struggling to adopt basic next-gen principles like modular architecture and user-driven configuration.
The technology has leaped ahead. Adoption is now the constraint.
Looking at the BioPhorum survey results, I'm proud that Apprentice consistently scores high across all the manifesto categories. But here's what really excites me: while most of the industry is still working to deliver on next-gen capabilities, we're already building what comes next — Agentic MES systems where AI will execute complex workflows autonomously when approved to do so while manufacturing teams focus on higher-value responsibilities. Imagine digital co-workers performing the tedious time-consuming tasks while keeping the human in the loop for GMP scenarios.
This represents a fundamental shift in how we think about manufacturing execution. Many vendors are still catching up to the full BioPhorum manifesto requirements. At Apprentice, we're already engineering the post-manifesto future — systems where AI agents truly understand manufacturing context and can act independently within defined parameters.
But here's the challenge: if organizations are still using legacy adoption approaches, they'll never be ready for the Agentic capabilities that are coming this year.
Here's where I need to be crystal clear about something: adoption is not the same as implementation.
Implementation is installing and configuring software. Adoption is transforming how teams think about and interact with manufacturing systems making it part of their daily life.
The legacy playbook for MES deployment — massive upfront planning, extensive customization, lengthy validation cycles, rigid training programs — fundamentally conflicts with next-gen MES principles. Then psychology keeps you from wanting to drive adoption because you inherently become afraid of change due to the effort it took! You can't take technology designed for agility, modularity, and user empowerment and roll it out using change management approaches built for inflexible, monolithic systems.
And you certainly can't realize the potential of Agentic MES using adoption strategies designed for paper-on-glass systems.
True adoption requires reimagining the entire journey:
From Project to Process Instead of treating MES as a multi-year capital project, we need to think about it as an ongoing capability that evolves with teams and processes.
From Training to Empowerment Traditional MES training is about teaching users to work within system constraints. Next-gen adoption is about empowering teams to configure systems that work the way they think and operate. Agentic adoption is about teaching teams to collaborate with AI agents as intelligent partners.
From IT-Led to User-Led The biggest shift? Putting scientists, operators, and quality managers in the driver's seat from day one. Not as end users to be trained, but as co-creators of their manufacturing environment — and as collaborators with AI agents that understand their workflows. “Connected Worker” is no longer enough, we need a Digitally Native Workforce.
Here's what keeps me up at night: every month that passes, the gap between available technology and organizational adoption grows wider.
Agentic MES is coming. Within months, we'll have AI agents that can autonomously author complex manufacturing workflows, optimize processes in real-time, and predict quality outcomes with unprecedented accuracy. Meanwhile, many teams are still fighting to get basic electronic batch records implemented effectively.
This isn't just about missing out on efficiency gains. It's about competitive advantage. Organizations that prepare now for Agentic MES adoption will fundamentally outperform those still struggling with legacy deployment approaches when these capabilities arrive.
To close this adoption gap, organizations need to focus on two fundamental areas:
1. Vendor Evaluation Revolution
2. Mindset and Change Management Transformation
For greenfield sites, this is a transformational opportunity to build operations around accelerated/agentic principles from day one. Even brownfield teams can get significant value by selectively adopting accelerated/agentic approaches for specific processes or pain points.
Looking at this BioPhorum data, I'm convinced we're at an inflection point. The next-gen capabilities outlined in the manifesto aren't visionary anymore — they're table stakes. The real competitive advantage now lies in Accelerated MES and Agentic MES capabilities.
But true adoption isn't about rolling out software. It's about embracing a fundamentally different relationship between manufacturing teams, their technology systems, and AI agents that can execute complex tasks autonomously.
The survey shows 45% of solutions have been implemented by a moderate range of suppliers. That's progress on the next-gen front. But the organizations that will dominate the next decade are already thinking beyond implementation to true Agentic adoption.
The question isn't whether Agentic MES will become the standard. It's whether your organization will lead the adoption transformation or spend years trying to catch up to technology that's already here.
What mindset are you ready to adopt?
%20(1)%20copy.png)